New York Car Dealers, Good or Not

We rated 710 car dealers in New York. 42 percent get a Buyers say yes and 16 percent a Mostly no. Around Syracuse NY 54 percent of lots earn a yes, the best share in the state.

• 710rated dealers
• 297Buyers say yes
• 111Mostly no
• 7metro lists

Pick a Metro

• New York NY 248 rated, 34% yes
• Rochester NY 131 rated, 46% yes
• Buffalo NY 125 rated, 43% yes
• Albany NY 108 rated, 44% yes
• Syracuse NY 84 rated, 54% yes
• Newark NJ 13 rated, 38% yes
• Burlington VT 1 rated, 0% yes

Top Scoring Dealers in New York

• Island Auto Group

  Used car dealer · 1580 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island · New York NY list

  Buyers say yes99 of 100

  4.9 stars from 5,240 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 70 reviewers left one or two stars across 5,240 reviews.

  Reviewers praise smooth process, easy process.

  Also listed on Yelp

  Call (929) 533-1749 Website Map

• Van Bortel Subaru of Rochester

  Subaru dealer · 4211 W Henrietta Rd, Rochester · Rochester NY list

  Buyers say yes99 of 100

  4.9 stars from 3,972 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 110 reviewers left one or two stars across 3,972 reviews.

  Reviewers praise no pressure sales, fair pricing.

  Also listed on Yelp, Cars.com, Carfax

  Call (585) 222-2277 Website Map

• West Herr Ford of Amherst

  Ford dealer · 2600 Millersport Hwy, Getzville · Buffalo NY list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.8 stars from 6,286 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 36 reviewers left one or two stars across 6,286 reviews.

  Reviewers praise no pressure sales.

  Also listed on Cars.com, Carfax

  Call (716) 342-3182 Website Map

• West Herr Subaru of Orchard Park

  Subaru dealer · 3559 Southwestern Blvd, Orchard Park · Buffalo NY list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.8 stars from 5,893 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 42 reviewers left one or two stars across 5,893 reviews.

  Also listed on Yelp

  Call (716) 508-4247 Website Map

• West Herr Nissan of Orchard Park

  Nissan dealer · 3580 Southwestern Blvd, Orchard Park · Buffalo NY list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.9 stars from 3,454 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 44 reviewers left one or two stars across 3,454 reviews.

  Reviewers praise quick process.

  Also listed on Yelp, Carfax, Kelley Blue Book

  Call (716) 954-8976 Website Map

• Vision Auto Group

  Used car dealer · 800 Panorama Trail S #100, Rochester · Rochester NY list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.9 stars from 2,807 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 48 reviewers left one or two stars across 2,807 reviews.

  Reviewers praise easy process, no pressure sales.

  Also listed on Facebook

  Call (585) 310-7025 Website Map

• West Herr Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram of Orchard Park

  Jeep dealer · 3599 Southwestern Blvd, Orchard Park · Buffalo NY list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.9 stars from 2,497 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 40 reviewers left one or two stars across 2,497 reviews.

  Reviewers praise quick process, no pressure sales.

  Also listed on Facebook

  Call (716) 954-8978 Website Map

• Audi Rochester

  Audi dealer · 3955 W Henrietta Rd, Rochester · Rochester NY list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.9 stars from 2,383 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 43 reviewers left one or two stars across 2,383 reviews.

  Reviewers praise no pressure sales.

  Also listed on Yelp

  Call (585) 332-5651 Website Map

• Garber Pre-Owned Super Center

  Used car dealer · 3890 W Henrietta Rd, Rochester · Rochester NY list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  4.9 stars from 1,137 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 38 reviewers left one or two stars across 1,137 reviews.

  Reviewers praise kind staff, quick process, no pressure sales.

  Call (585) 699-1223 Website Map

• Northtown Subaru Transit

  Subaru dealer · 6374 Transit Rd, Depew · Buffalo NY list

  Buyers say yes98 of 100

  5 stars from 468 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 156 reviewers left one or two stars across 468 reviews.

  Reviewers praise no pressure sales.

  Call (716) 614-3500 Website Map

• West Herr Ford of Hamburg

  Ford dealer · 5025 Camp Rd, Hamburg · Buffalo NY list

  Buyers say yes97 of 100

  4.8 stars from 7,609 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 32 reviewers left one or two stars across 7,609 reviews.

  Also listed on Facebook

  Call (716) 337-5289 Website Map

• West Herr Chevrolet of Williamsville

  Chevrolet dealer · 8040 Transit Rd, Williamsville · Buffalo NY list

  Buyers say yes97 of 100

  4.8 stars from 7,551 reviews.

  • Only 1 in 30 reviewers left one or two stars across 7,551 reviews.

  Also listed on Yelp, DealerRater

  Call (716) 406-6140 Website Map